Debate! Should Israel pull out of the hostage agreement? | Rules of Engagement

Get an inside look at the current debate gripping #Israel! Jennifer Sutton, Executive Director of Council for a Secure America, moderates this debate between IDF Col. (Res) Gabi Siboni and Col. (Res) Grisha Yakubovich on the merits of the current #hostage agreement between Israel and #Hamas. They’ll cover the important arguments for and against the agreement and whether or not it’s worth the price Israel will inevitably pay. Learn how the current agreement has divided Israeli society and how it will affect Israel for years to come. JNS will host its inaugural International Policy Summit on Monday, April 28, 2025. This daylong event will convene government officials, policymakers, diplomats, security experts, leaders of pro-Israel organizations, and influencers for vital discussions aimed at addressing Israel's critical challenges and opportunities in a post-October 7 world. Registration at this point is for invitees only. However, you can submit a request for registration through the following link: https://reg.eventact.com/form?Event=iUJEAAA&c=iOAE&Form=iZpQAAA&Account=iAA&lang=en&hc&login=462734005425 If you liked this video, you’re going to love @JNS_TV - don’t forget to hit the subscribe button! Catch every story from Israel and the Jewish World: Latest news: https://bit.ly/jewish_news_service Subscribe to our free newsletter: https://bit.ly/subscribe_to_JNS You can also join the fight against media bias! Donate here: https://bit.ly/Support-JNS Chapters 00:00 The Moral Dilemma of Hostage Negotiations 08:10 Strategic Implications of the Hostage Deal 16:04 Balancing National Security and Humanitarian Concerns 24:03 The Future of Israeli Security and Society 34:42 Understanding Life in Israel 35:08 The Principle of Not Negotiating with Terrorists 36:39 The Price of War and Its Impact on Families 39:48 The Future of Israel's Security Strategy 42:12 The Role of the Government in Military Decisions 45:24 The Risks of Hostage Negotiations 48:02 Personal Perspectives on Kidnapping and War 55:57 The Moral Dilemma of Releasing Terrorists 01:01:40 The Line Between Negotiation and Surrender 01:04:04 Concluding Thoughts on Israel's Future